The job of directing a new play is wildly different than directing a dance-driven musical based on a movie. I don't know that she's ever been known as an "actor's director."
BULLETS didn't fail because of the Allen controversy (which was pretty much nonexistant at the time, and he was just coming off Oscar-winning Blue Jasmine and Midnight in Paris) –– it failed because it got terrible reviews, had a strange tone, and was a mess. But the director shoulders at least some of the blame.
BIG FISH's failures were in the oversized scale of the show, the structure that deviated from the film in an inferior way, and the poor music/lyrics/book. But again, as the director who was involved for years before it went to Broadway, some of the blame belongs to her.
She hasn't seemed to crack LITTLE DANCER after all these workshops and mixed-review tryouts either.
The brilliance of THE PRODUCERS was that she (and Nathan & cast) was able to distract from the fact that the material isn't very good.
None of the above means that POTUS can't succeed. It simply means she's trying something much different than she's done before. And with a play like this, the casting announcement should be enough to tell us if it will or won't recoup.
Updated On: 2/6/22 at 12:54 PM