Posted: 10/23/25 at 9:32am
Mike66 said: "Scarywarhol said: "Mike66 said: "No great disrespect to The Smith or PJ Clarkes -- but they are, in my opinion -- overpriced, underserviced, bland and boring -- and much too crowded (and loud). Sure -- if you want that 'I wait 45 minutes and then have 30 minutes to eat the cold french fries' vibe, But I'm sure it's not just marketing that keeps them crowded.
The Lincoln Center area (1/2 mile in each direction) has at least a dozen really good dining experiences, for a (NYC) reasonable price. You dont have to settle for the places across the street.
"
You going to name these restaurants or just criticize other people's reasonable suggestions? It's a notoriously poor area for dining. Been here fifteen years and don't have a go-to by Lincoln Center.
Of course if we're defining "immediate vicinity" as an entire mile of Manhattan..."
I didnt criticize anyone. I disagreed with an opinion. Ive never met or spoken to the person who posted -- on what basis would I ever criticize him/her?(Although it seems to be sort of common on these threads).
I defined the scope of search as being 'The Lincoln Center area' which I went on to define as ONE HALF mile in each direction. That's different from your making it the 'immediate vicinity' (which I really cant quantify in any way.). And then you turned what I said into 'an entire mile of Manhattan'. That's not what I said. I said 1/2 mile -- 10 city blocks -- (although they are all between 58th to the South (7 blocks away) and 69th to the North (four blocks away), now that I actually look at a map.)
As to my go-tos -- I sent a private message to the person who asked for recommendations. Perhaps he/she will consider the choices, perhaps not. He/She asked, so I sen them along. I dont have any financial or rooting interest in any of these places, and dont want to do their advertising for them. (Or open myself up for more attacks, now that I think about it.)
Stay safe
It is absolutely bizarre to say "I don't want to do their advertising for them" when asked for restaurant recommendations. What planet are you from?