Posted: 11/28/21 at 4:56pm
HogansHero said: "@OlBlueEyes No nits on your explanation. I think there is a conversation that might be had about the why, but not about the observation. Re Soupy, it made your point effectively. The nit would have been cured by leaving out the "had."
[I encountered Soupy in a doctors' office once. Even behind a much older façade, the expression was unmistakable.]
I was just joshing, Hogan. I respect you too much to give you a hard time over that. In fact, usually I would check, but it was about 4:00 am and I was falling asleep.
That name just popped into my head and I couldn't remember how long it had been since I had thought of him. I remember I think that he got into trouble when he asked his audience to take those paper bills from their parents' wallets and mail them to him.
Do you think that Oscar was too soft to be considered a great writer? I can't ask to compare Oscar and Stephen as book writers since Sondheim didn't write the books, but fifty years from now, if the country still exists, how will critics compare Hammerstein musicals to Sondheim musicals.
They will be compared. Maybe this isn't the right thread for a critical discussion.