BrodyFosse123 said: "Audra’s affected “Rose’s Turn” was an eye roll watch. I’m sure at the Majestic Theatre it plays better but with the intimate camera in her face you could see her working her performance. It was too much “I’m Audra McDonald and I’m acting these lyrics better than any other actress has ever.” Her acting wasn’t anchored to the music so there was a disconnect. That’s whereall the other actresses who’ve played the role differed - they acted “Rose’s Turn” to the music, not the other way around. Audra was doing a play interpretation not a musical interpretation of “Rose’s Turn.”"
Not being anchored to the music is primarily due to the truncating of the song for broadcast and the conductor rushing some moments that are timed better in the theater. I loved it in the theater and appreciated getting to see the camera right up close, looking down at her tonsils. And in many ways, yeah, she did act it better than some of the other women to play Rose...so what?
I agree with what most have said about the song choices and was surprised at how boring some of the shows with the most buzz looked. Maybe Happy Ending's number was a terrible showcase to support a win for Criss later in the evening (especially considering how strong Jordan and Groff were in the representative numbers), and musically, it didn't come close to something like Operation Mincemeat, which I find in general was the more dynamic score. Dead Outlaw was D.O.A. in my book. I would never see that show unless it was part of a touring package, and the same goes for Pirates! (they should tour that one, though). I love RWHC and was hoping they'd choose a more representative number, but while the music was pleasant, it doesn't give you a clear idea of what to expect if you buy a ticket.
It's telling that the best number of the night was the Hamilton reunion, and I was thrilled to see even the ensemble was back in formation. I don't understand the continued hate for DeBose on here; she's one of the most eye-catching performers, and she looked fantastic last night (the hair! Love). She was a terrific host, the best kind of theater kid try-hard all of us are deep down.