SPOILER ALERT
I was at the first preview as well. Indeed, the show is already in a pretty good shape for a first preview, but it definitely needs A LOT OF WORK bookwise. The character of Earl seems basically non-existent to me in the first act. The way they present it makes him look like a typical cranky Southern jerk, but because Earl never physically hurts Jenna (though he indeed threatens her) and there are indeed some sweet moments that tell you that it's really his insecurity that leads to his bad temper, he is not bad enough to justify Jenna's hooking up with the married doctor while she is married herself. There are even times when I feel sorry for him and the doctor's wife who makes the cameo when Jenna is in labor. Of course, some may argue smashing a guitar and threatening is sort of domestic violence (just to imagine 8 guitars will be destroyed every week... Or perhaps it's a specially designed prop that lasts longer?), but personally I would desire more dynamics between Jenna and Earl for the audience to truly understand her motive and to approve her affair.
I haven't watched the film yet, but as far as the musical goes, it's basically a story about cheating (there is definitely something else, but this is what is stuck with me). Jenna cheats her husband, though for a somewhat passable reason. The doctor cheats his wife because...she is doing residency? And they think this can possibly justify him flirting with and banging his patient? Cal, the cook, cheats his wife, though he suspects she is a lesbian... Becky, another waitress in the diner, cheats her husband with Cal, and yet she says she still loves him? So almost half the major characters are having affairs for not much sympathizable reasons. Kudos! However, there is indeed a redeeming factor.
Click Here To Toggle Spoiler Content
After Jenna gives birth to Lulu, she breaks up with the doctor. It seems I was one of the very handful cheering for this in the theatre though...
Hey, at least it passes the bechdel test!
Musicwise, the score is strong and sara's songs are really enchanting. But don't set your expectation too high because the audience will be largely comprised of Sara's fans, many of whom are rare or even first-time theatergoers. They literally howl whenever someone belts a high note. Imagine the whole house CHEERS in the middle of She Used to Be Mine... Ugh... That's what happened tonight and it immediately got me out of the scene. Of course it's not the fault of the creatives, but still...
Updated On: 3/26/16 at 02:01 AM