I also did the marathon yesterday (I believe the first marathon day of the Broadway run?) and what an amazing way to spend a day. The hours flew by and I was constantly enraptured by Kushner’s text. Each scene is so essential, so full of insight, humor, and soaring language, so full of quotable lines and memorable moments, so full of impeccable use of rhetoric.
This production has two stars: Kushner’s text and Nathan Lane. Lane is giving a career-best performance, bringing an authenticity to the world that is sometimes missing in his cast mates and a full understanding of the character and play. His Roy Cohn embodies the contradictions of the man and the immortal summation of him as a bully, coward, and victim. You will hate Roy Cohn but feel for him.
The rest of the cast gives strong performance but largely feels like the text is doing the work. Garfield is very affected, and its effectiveness varies greatly. His Prior lives in a breathy, upper register of his voice, which is a choice that leaves him little place to go in terms of vocality. In much of Perestroika especially, he seems more histrionic rather than the wrath of God.
Which is a similar issue I have with Nathan Stewart-Jarrett’s Belize, who I think is my weak link in the cast. I am loathe to compare him to Jeffrey Wright, but Wright was so perfectly high-status; he never needed to shout down Louis or Roy, he was constantly so certain in his strength and regality and his shade cut like a cold knife. Stewart-Jarrett just doesn’t have that and does resort to getting into a shouting match, which undercuts Belize’s strength.
Beth Malone’s Angel was such a nice surprise- far different than I expected. Her Angel isn’t biblical imperiousness and power, but a sort of... rocker chick who is very assured of her badassery.
Marienne Elliott’s production itself is a stunner. The triple revolving set pieces of the first part look cobbled from various 80s design trends, but then their eventual removal is a brilliant way to support Perestroika’s sprawl, as each scene is framed in light and neon. Her layering of scenes in the second part is especially brilliant, and heaven and Prior’s return is remarkable.
"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."