jimmycurry01 said: "ljay889 said: "Not trying to start a fight, but we don’t need to be reminded EVERY time that there’s a London cast recording. We clearly know that, but the album subpar in every way compared to what is heard on Broadway. The orchestra sounds small and low on the album and every performance is better on Broadway."
It may be inferior, but you also have to admit that we often live in a Broadway World fantasy land where we pretend that money isn't a thing, and it makes sense to add on another recording to the five already in existence.
Finding the London recording inferior doesn't make another recording financially viable, and the changes were still preserved for posterity, so if this version licensed, there is a reference. Pretending the recording doesn't exist, and yes many here seem to do just that, isn't going to make it go away and a new one come into existence. I don't mean to come off as a prick, but Broadway World has a way of... well, being Broadway World about these things."
That's a lot of words to say absolutely nothing. Seriously, ljay889 should just copy and paste the exact same comment as before, because it remains a fitting rebuttal to your argument of nothing.
No one is arguing the financial viability of a new recording. We are simply stating that, on the basis of artistic worth, this specific production deserves one. That's it. Saying the London production was recorded is irrelevant because it is not this specific production with this specific cast, which is what people are commenting on. (Bringing it up is also unnecessary, as ljay pointed out, because everyone knows. It's not ignorance of a different recording that's leading so many to request this one.) Saying it wouldn't be financially viable is also irrelevant, because no one is arguing that it would be. They are simply saying they would like a recording of this production and mourning the possibility since it is unlikely to be. Telling them they're wrong to want such a thing because it's expensive is unnecessary, and frankly, tacky.
It's okay to let people feel sad about something--or feel anything really--without trying to rebut their feelings.
Updated On: 6/21/22 at 08:22 PM