I wasn't a big Dear Evan Hansen fan when I saw it on Broadway. I even thought Ben Platt's acclaimed performance was a little overwrought at times. And I'm well aware that many people hate the plot and the character of Evan.
But the musical has been the biggest original Broadway hit since Hamilton, and it's been a touring juggernaut - at least in the United States.
So I'm not surprised there's a film adaptation, or that the producers wanted Platt to play the role in the movie. Yeah, I know, he's got connections, but he won a bunch of awards and a lot of critical praise for his work as Evan Hansen.
The irony, to me, is that we usually bemoan Hollywood's inevitable use of non-theater performers in musicals in favor of bigger names. If nothing else, we're going to see Platt - in a role he created - play it on film.
Will it work? I have no idea. I also have no idea if Julianne Moore, a wonderful actor, can sing.
This is hardly the first example of movies picking stars or actors they think will be good in the part play characters who are much younger. Judas and the Black Messiah - a serious drama - is only the most recent example, with LaKeith Stanfield (28 at the time) playing a teenager while Daniel Kaluuya, past 30, won an Oscar portraying Fred Hampton (killed at 21).
I do agree wtth those who question whether Platt is such a big star that his presence in the movie will make or break it. I wonder if Platt's acting style as Evan will be as effective on film as on stage. I wonder if the plot will just not interest the average moviegoer. And no, I don't love Platt's hair and makeup from what I've seen in the trailer.
But part of watching a lot of theater, and especially musicals, is learning to look past things that aren't necessarily realistic. As someone else mentioned, I'll forget about that stuff a few minutes into the movie.
I neither loved nor hated the stage musical. But I would rather it not suck, if for no other reason than to encourage successful adaptations of musicals and plays. I'm hoping all the ones that are arriving this year are good, and that at least one is great.