I'm slowly working my way through this lovely thread, but in the meantime, I thought I'd add my own story.
Two late-middle-age couples from somewhere in the vicinity of NYC, but not within the five boroughs (they were very chatty; I gleaned one couple had a daughter in school in Manhattan, so they'd been visiting a lot) sat behind me at TIME STANDS STILL. I don't know how or why they came to be in possession of their tickets, but they had *no idea* about *anything* relating to the play.
One of the husband spent the 10 minutes before curtain quizzing his friends about what they thought it would be about. Most of them assumed it was a light comedy, for some reason. But my favorite comment was, "Well, the title -- TIME STANDS STILL. Hmm. I suppose that could refer to a lot of things."
At intermission, after a lengthy post-applause pause, one of the wives said, "Well... this is awfully cheery." They all got a big kick out of that.
CHURCH DOOR TOUCAN GAY MARKETING PUPPIES MUSICAL THEATER STAPLES PERIOD OIL BITCHY SNARK HOLES