Firstly, kudos to the people that financed this movie, and marketed it as an indie, knowing it'll be DOA at the box office but do better when it's streaming, and will likely be remembered down the line come awards season.
As for the film itself, as a huge fan of the original music, I was hard pressed to hate all the changes. But overall, I have to say I was impressed by almost all the work Condon made. And there were many moments where I became overwhelmed with emotion. The musical numbers worked a lot better than I thought they would,
I think my real frustration came in some of the jail cell scenes. For some reason, I feel like Condon didn't trust in the material or the performances, or got nervous about the confined spaced so there were just many camera angles, so many cuts to the next shot, so many handheld jerky moments. I really just wanted to sit with some of these moments but at times they seem so rushed.
Which is funny because he really did a great job of capturing performances. Tonatiuh was outstanding,in a performance in a role that could easily be rritating in so many close-ups, but he modulated for the camera and qiuckly projected the warmth you needed to see. Luna felt slightly miscast as times - as I don't think he translated in the musical number, but I think overall he shined brightly when he really needed to in the real-world scenes. And Lopez was lovely in her roles. She sang it fine, danced it great, and did well to make her performance fit the world of the film. It's not like movie-within-a-movie is especially deep: it's colorful, it's arch, it's camp b-movie. She was overall great.
"Hey little girls, look at all the men in shiny shirts and no wives!" - Jackie Hoffman, Xanadu, 19 Feb 2008