so yes, there are some very creaky book moments. particularly in act 2, glaring problems emerge: Tamara is in love with two people, we are told immediately, but then seems to only love one of them (or we are shown very little of the love for the other). and i found myself eyerolling at the somewhat insane demands of Rafaela: she wanted to live in an open lesbian relationship in 1930s Europe and was mad at Tamara for.... reading the violent, hateful room? so yes, there are problems the show cant get around. and yes, the score never takes off entirely- serviceable, moving/pleasant in the moment but nothing to write home about. so i get the complaints about the core of this, which is good but not at at all great.
but everything else is great. i dont say that lightly. im shocked how much i enjoyed the spectacle/accoutrement that they managed here. i thought the set was simple but sexy, smart. the story is undeniably compelling and never loses us. europe in 1933? we know whats coming but i never felt myself thinking "ok lets get on with it" the way i did with harmony.
but mostly i thought this cast was so perfect that i could forgive most everything else. its not just that they are all giving great performances, they seem to be embodying these characters and making them their own, and i see rachel chavkin hands all over this cast.. andrew samonsky (that voice! wow) and amber iman (double wow) are each fantastic- Iman sizzles whenever she steps center stage, and sings those songs like very few others can. (hard to imagine carmen cusack in this role, as great as she is, with the way iman has developed it). George Abud is outstanding- hilarious and terrifying and demands award notice. did they write that role *for* Natalie Joy Johnson? its tailor made for her. and beth leavel is giving a master class in line delivery-- and the entire left orchestra was sniffling audibly during her touching song at the end.
but the show would fall apart without true stage presence at the center of it, and espinosa's performance tonight surprised me: i was expecting vocal pyrotechnics (and didnt get as many as i thought we would, shes struggling with some of those unforgiving notes), but i was not expecting such a rich committed portrayal. i know she is given some creaky, sloppy dialogue (to rafaella, to herself) but she rises above it. the girl can act, and as fine as she was as Maureen 15 years ago and as powerful as she sounds on a thousand youtube elphaba videos, i was not expecting this at all. its a beast of a role and she sold me, hook/line/sinker.
so count me pleasantly surprised. i cant see this lasting very long without rave reviews and awards, and even then, its a hard sell (being marketed kinda strangely). the orchestra was mostly full but not entirely. id recommend sitting house right over house left-- video projections were sometimes hard to see and much less is going on across the stage.