jonah3500 said: "I was at the invited dress rehearsal on Saturday, and I know you’re not supposed to judge an invited dress, since it’s just a rehearsal. But I think that anything significant will have been fixed if it’s the last day before previews. Anyway here’s what I wrote on the way back:
Remember Something Rotten!? That gloriously chaotic show about two writers that compete with Shakespeare by writing a musical about breakfast? If only that were similar enough to Mrs. Doubtfire to necessitate the use of the same writers.
Don’t get me wrong: I loved Mrs. Doubtfire a LOT. The cast was phenomenal, and the songs were great, if sometimes hard to hear. (That can be excused, though, since it was an invited dress.) But it seems that the writing team of the Kirkpatrick brothers and John O’Farrell can only write chaos and hilarity. (Doubtfire’s version of Something Rotten’s omelette number is a number about cooking chicken, with 10 tap dancing Siri chefs.)
If you’ve seen the movie of Mrs. Doubtfire, it may seem like that’s the kind of writer a show like this needs. But here’s the thing: Something Rotten was pure musical comedy with a dash of heart mixed in. But Doubtfire is heart, sautéed in pure musical comedy. And when it comes time to write a song with real soul, it seems the writers slink immediately to “Love matters.” And this message is absolutely fine to have in a musical, as long as it’s not thrown at the audience constantly. So that’s one reason Doubtfire isn’t as earnest as it could, and should, be.
And then there’s the inevitable comparisons to Tootsie, last season’s musical comedy that won over everybody’s hearts, until it suddenly didn’t. Tootsie closed last year after theater fans rejected it for being anti-trans and sexist. And this show, while it could have the same problem, could not be more different. Tootsie is about taking a job from women by pretending to be one. To quote Rob McClure at BroadwayCon, though, “We tried very hard to make sure the punchline was never that it was a man in a dress. Because that’s not funny.” Furthermore, Mrs. Doubtfire is about a man taking a job as a nanny to be with his family. Those two things could not be more different. And even if Tootsie was as sensitive as Doubtfire, the quick changes are less impressive. So that’s something Doubtfire has going for it.
I would be remiss without mentioning Rob McClure’s amazing role in this show. He knocks it out of the park, performing an insanely difficult role with ease and grace in a way that few performers can. He carries so much of the show, though, that I don’t know what it would be like without him.
To summarize, Mrs. Doubtfire is a brilliantly hilarious show that has trouble finding the balance between brilliantly hilarious and touching, but when it tips towards hilarious, it’s brilliant in a way that most musicals aren’t. I’m really glad I got to see it."
I enjoyed reading your assessment of the show, but have to disagree with one point you sort of stated as a given. You wrote: Tootsie closed last year after theater fans rejected it for being anti-trans and sexist. I disagree. Tootsie did not fail for the reasons you stated. It failed because it was not good. Bad score, mediocre direction and choreography, cheesy sets. That is why Tootsie failed.