MadsonMelo said: "Funny people are not liking Maslany or calling her miscast.
That’s was the exactly the same response that Michelle Dockery got from UK boards"
I know I went into some great length of detail about Maslany earlier in the thread, but I'd like to repeat myself because I found myself really into her performance. There's many moments of hers I'm still thinking about a week later.
It's not false that Maslany is not playing this role at all like Dunaway. The two cannot be anymore different, I think. I will be honest, I was a bit cool on Maslany in her earlier scenes. I did feel like she was just hitting one night, the right one, no doubt, but one note nonetheless. But something shifts with her performance, for me anyway, during the "I'm mad as hell" speech. It's the first time the camera is on her I think, and I really got to marvel at all of the acting she was doing way down below (I was in one of the final rows in balcony.) You could see her coming alive as Beale was falling apart. From then on, I was totally transfixed. The way she played the scene with Goldwyn (you know the one I'm talking about) was incredible to me, and deeply disturbing. Her Diana is not a svelt, witty, temptress type. She is rather an anxious, ferocious, almost distubed and disconnected individual. I know I said this anecdote before, but I kept thinking about her age in relation to Goldwyn. She completely embodied to me what he says about her: "she's a product of the TV era, she grew up on Bugs Bunny" or something to that effect. While I know the show technically takes place in the 70's, she read to me as a Diana of the 21st century, a frazzled young girl who has seen the politicians and media figures of her day behave like lunatics, who has grown up in the era where violence is so common that she's become desensitized to it. Almost like one of those FOX News girls who have capitalized on the fractured political landscape of our time for fame and notoriety. It's a bold choice to make with the character, but to me, it ultimately pays off.
I always feel like when it comes to an Ivo production, there's the performance that an actor would give in a show, and then there is the performance they would give in an Ivo von Hove production of a show. He's shows are so completely their own beast, and he is so disinterested in convention, that you have to rise to whatever specific themes or ideas he's trying to highlight. So maybe in a regular staging of the show, Maslany wouldn't work at all, but I think in this production, she is completely in tandem with what Ivo is trying to achieve, for better or worse.
Sorry for writing an entire essay on Maslany's performance, I know some of you probably don't think it warrants it (which is completely ok to think.) But to me, she really got under my skin and made me very uncomfortable, in the best way. I do hope she finds some variation in her earlier scenes, and I look forward to returning to the production again to check. I also really enjoyed seeing her in Mary Page Marlowe this Summer, and I'm thrilled she's becoming a fixture on the NY theatre scene.