NOWaWarning said: "The Pam and Tommy show is quite well done, although it could have easily been condensed into a movie. Pam is by far the most sympathetic and interesting character in it and Lily James is SCARY good. But the whole thing, unfortunately, is clouded by Pam’s disapproval. Because they make the violation and lack of consent the central theme, them carrying on without Pam’s permission makes it feel pretty hollow.
Anyhow, this casting news has me so excited! I’m debating whether I should buy a ticket for her opening night. While I’m sure the excitement will be palpable, I’m worried she might end up needing more rehearsal time and need to postpone. Or if everything goes according to schedule, she might need some shows under her belt to settle in. A conundrum."
It's interesting to me because I've found the critical reviews very positive for James, lukewarm for Stan and lukewarm towards the entire series. Viewers feedback on social media being far less positive, namely that the show is poorly written and terribly paced, as well as boring. I found it boring as well. How ones makes porn and icons boring is beyond me. I find it a slog to get through.
As far as James performance, I'm on the fence. She is encased in so much latex, for me it is such a disconnect. Is the performance a revelation or the makeup FX? To me, Pam is portrayed as warm and sympathetic but like many actors thirsty for awards recognition, James leans into a lot of mannerisms Pam used in interviews and public appearances, so when she is shown in her private life I don't feel we are seeing a grounded and balanced portrayal. I think she is far more intelligent than she is shown here. I feel like her and especially Tommy are portrayed as simpletons. Tommy has almost no complexity, which may be true but it doesn't dramatize well.
Also, when the series is supposedly telling about the trauma Pam endured and continues to, it feels very icky what the creators are doing with this project. Creating more trauma and exploitation.
In contrast, I felt like American Crime Story: Impeachment created real tension and disgust during Monica's detainment and questioning. The episode with Pam being questioned by lawyers felt superficial and provocative. I wasn't believing it.
"The sexual energy between the mother and son really concerns me!"-random woman behind me at Next to Normal
"I want to meet him after and bang him!"-random woman who exposed her breasts at Rock of Ages, referring to James Carpinello