Broadway Legend Joined: 3/23/17
Tag said: "This role IS Patti's next Tony. Hands down.
Patti LuPone is 70. Miranda has twin "tween-age" girls. Do the math.
Catherine Zeta Jones on the other hand...
JSquared2 said: "Tag said: "This role IS Patti's next Tony. Hands down.
Patti LuPone is 70. Miranda has twin "tween-age" girls. Do the math.
Catherine Zeta Jones on the other hand..."
I also think Patti is probably the best choice to bring this role to the stage and I'm sure they would age up Miranda's daughters. Patti could also read younger. Powerful and successful women in New York tend to have their children later in life. Patti is a wonderful actress and while Meryl's icy subtle performance is perfect for screen, it probably wouldn't read onstage. Patti would be brilliant.
Catherine Zeta Jones on the other hand is boring and should never set foot on the Broadway stage again.
lucas_glenn said: "Christine Baranski for Miranda and I could see someone like Sierra Boggess for Andie"
Christine Baranski would be amazing! Though she does look a lot like Anna Wintour... maybe too close for producers' comfort?
I think they should cast an unknown for Andie, while Emily could be someone we already know.
Broadway Legend Joined: 3/23/17
GeorgeandDot said: "JSquared2 said: "Tag said: "This role IS Patti's next Tony. Hands down.
Patti LuPone is 70. Miranda has twin "tween-age" girls. Do the math.
Catherine Zeta Jones on the other hand..."
I also think Patti is probably the best choice to bring this role to the stage and I'm sure they would age up Miranda's daughters. Patti could also read younger. Powerful and successful women in New York tend to have their children later in life. Patti is a wonderful actress and while Meryl's icy subtle performance is perfect for screen, it probably wouldn't read onstage. Patti would be brilliant.
"Age up"? So she would have 30 year old twins who lived at home with their parents and just had to have the new Harry Potter book immediately??
I agree with those who have suggested that Miranda should be a non Singing role. She’d be much more powerful and intimidating if she simply had strong book scenes and presence without breaking into song. For example: The biggest problem (IMHO) with LaChiusa’s BERNARDA ALBA is giving the titular character songs. The songs he wrote for the Matriarch let us in to her psyche and allow us to empathize with the character when we shouldn’t. She would have been much more terrifying if she didn’t have her songs. Save for maybe the finale... that’s a chilling and terrifying ending to BA.... I digress.
In my fantasy casting— Miranda would be a non singing role; with Cate Blanchett as Miranda.
I think having only one song late in the show for Miranda would be effective. I so wish this was a David Yazbeck project.
HenryTDobson said: "I think having only one song late in the show for Miranda would be effective.I so wish this was a David Yazbeck project."
Exactly what I was thinking. Give Miranda an emotional 11-o'clock ballad and don't let her sing another word.
Christine Baranski would be such an amazing fit.
Vanessa Williams?
Chorus Member Joined: 5/2/19
raddersons said: "HenryTDobson said: "I think having only one song late in the show for Miranda would be effective.I so wish this was a David Yazbeck project."
Exactly what I was thinking. Give Miranda an emotional 11-o'clock ballad and don't let her sing another word.
Christine Baranski would be such an amazing fit."
A lot of these women are too old. Miranda isn’t 70. I think giving her some singing is still necessary. She’s the most interesting character in the film. I think having her not sing would make her too dull.
I could see Vanessa Williams in the role (she’s already played it essentially in Ugly Betty).
JSquared2 said: "GeorgeandDot said: "JSquared2 said: "Tag said: "This role IS Patti's next Tony. Hands down.
Patti LuPone is 70. Miranda has twin "tween-age" girls. Do the math.
Catherine Zeta Jones on the other hand..."
I also think Patti is probably the best choice to bring this role to the stage and I'm sure they would age up Miranda's daughters. Patti could also read younger. Powerful and successful women in New York tend to have their children later in life. Patti is a wonderful actress and while Meryl's icy subtle performance is perfect for screen, it probably wouldn't read onstage. Patti would be brilliant.
"Age up"? So she would have 30 year old twins who lived at home with their parents and just had to have the new Harry Potter book immediately??"
You could easily write around this. Also, I wouldn't be surprised if they completely change it from the Harry Potter book since we haven't had a new Harry Potter book in like a decade. I feel like it's easy to write it so she could be older.
Broadway Legend Joined: 3/23/17
Music_Maker42 said: "raddersons said: "HenryTDobson said: "I think having only one song late in the show for Miranda would be effective.I so wish this was a David Yazbeck project."
Exactly what I was thinking. Give Miranda an emotional 11-o'clock ballad and don't let her sing another word.
Christine Baranski would be such an amazing fit."
A lot of these women are too old. Miranda isn’t 70. I think giving her some singing is still necessary. She’s the most interesting character in the film. I think having her not sing would make her too dull.
I could see Vanessa Williams in the role (she’s already played it essentially in Ugly Betty).
And throw in Michael Urie in the Stanley Tucci role and you've got an onstage UGLY BETTY reunion.
I feel like Laura Benanti could be a good Miranda. She has a sort of quiet snark and she exudes a strong alpha woman presence. She has also admitted to always reading much older than she actually is. I feel like with some rewites she could be a good Miranda.
It does NO good to "dreamcast" Miranda without knowing the vocal range that it's being written for. Elton could be writing it for a soprano. He could be writing it for a Broadway belter. It could need more of a rock voice, or a jazz voice, or maybe it's a "Rex Harrison-type" role. Same goes for Andie and all the other roles. Such intense speculation usually leads to disappointment.
I am sure we will find out more as they start doing workshops and further development on the piece.
This feels like Helen St. Clair (before Bullets came to Bway) all over again.
Stand-by Joined: 4/24/18
Incredible as I think she is, I'd hate to waste Laura Benanti's talent in a musical if her character is only singing like 1 or 2 songs.
SomethingPeculiar said: "It does NO good to "dreamcast" Miranda without knowing the vocal range that it's being written for. Elton could be writing it for a soprano. He could be writing it for a Broadway belter. It could need more of a rock voice, or a jazz voice, or maybe it's a "Rex Harrison-type" role. Same goes for Andie and all the other roles. Such intense speculation usually leads to disappointment.
I amsurewe will find out more as they start doing workshops and further development on the piece.
This feels like Helen St. Clair (beforeBullets came to Bway) all over again."
It's just fun?? If you don't want to speculate, you don't have to!
Music by Elton John
Lyrics by Shaina Taub
Book by Paul Rudnick
Music Supervision by Nadia DiGiallonardo
Directed by Anna D. Shapiro
Krystina Alabado as Andy Sachs
Etai Benson as Nate Angstrom
Mario Cantone as Nigel Owens
Nicholas Christopher as Christian Thompson
Leslie Hiatt reading Stage Directions
Anne Hollister as Kara Nichols
Brian Kerwin as Irv Ravitz
Jo Lampert as Lily Hunter
Emily Skinner as Miranda Priestly
Helen Yorke as Emily Charlton
Ensemble: Sydney Charles, Britney Coleman, Dayna Dantzler, Tyrone Davis Jr, Henry Gottfried, Molly Hager, Katie Lee Hill, Jessie Hooker-Bailey, Liana Hunt, Christopher Innvar, Brian Krauss, Nikka Lanzarone
Music Director/Piano: Nadia DiGiallonardo
Keyboard: James Olmstead
Guitar/Cello: Yair Evnine
Bass: Lee Nadel
Drums/Percussion: Spencer Cohen
Production Stage Manager: Holly Coombs
Stage Manager: Matthew Kurtis Lutz
Sound Board Operator: Nick Borisjuk
Production Assistants: Kelsy Durkin, Saori Yokoo
Music Assistant: Alexander Greenberg
Copyist: Stephen Kopel
Special Thanks: Buena Vista Theatrical, Bob Cohen, Isaac Hurwitz, Connor Brockmeier, Darren DeVerna, Nevin Steinberg
Side Note: I was not in attendance; this was posted publicly on social media.
Emily Skinner as Miranda is INTERESTING! And Helene Yorke is great casting as Emily.
Broadway Star Joined: 10/6/18
I LOVE Emily Skinner as Miranda! I think she would be perfect in that role. Also, a lot of the Waitress ensemble are involved in this along with the music director Nadia.
Didn't Krystina Alabado JUST get to Mean Girls?
YvanEhtNioj said: "Didn't Krystina Alabado JUST get to Mean Girls?"
So? It's just a reading. A full production could be a year+ away, and maybe none of these actors will continue on with the show (or maybe all of them will, time will tell). Mario Cantone also did the readings of Mrs. Doubtfire.
YvanEhtNioj said: "Didn't Krystina Alabado JUST get to Mean Girls?"
Does it matter? It’s a one-day reading on her day off.
Alright, alright. My bad geeez..
Videos