Y'all.
Y'all.
It's been MONTHS of this. Now I admit, it's been a bad day and I probably should just go on ignoring this, but If I see one more pearl-clutching comment about how inappropriate a Soprano Rose is, I'm going to do three things:
1. Beat my head against the wall repeatedly.
2. After bandaging my battered head, remind you all that everyone here lost their minds for Imelda Staunton's Rose when she basically just screams the entire role. (I loved Imelda's Rose too but Merman she ain't.)
3. Direct you all to the recording of Audra's Rose's turn that's been hanging out on Youtube this entire time, taken at a Carnagie Hall concert two years ago, where she employs a mix throughout the song rather than a full belt. Does it sound like Merman or Lupone, no, but it's zero percent an inappropriate sound for the score. https://youtube.com/watch?v=btyImEX-VNI
End of the day - Rose is a King Lear, a Hamlet, a Hedda Gabler. It is a mountain of a role and a performer of this caliber, regardless of vocal approach, can succeed as long as it is grounded in the character.
...For god sakes we had a tenor Sweeney Todd on Broadway with raised keys and y'all lost your minds for him. Give it a rest, y'all.