PipingHotPiccolo said: ""I don't think any of us who aren't a Black woman get to question how they interpret this material and production as presented."
if I am understanding this correctly, it is completely insane. I must be mistaken, because it seems like you're saying only Black women can question this production's interpretation, and surely no one can be that off-the-reservation delusional (particularly in a setting of anonymous posting where no one's race or gender is readily apparent)? When will this "Only X Can Talk About Y, Those Are The Rules We Made Up" fever break?
If that IS what you are saying, sorry, you're in the wrong space, go elsewhere with this nonsense, and let us (of all colors, genders)continue doing whatever we damn well please while you scream at the sky in vain."
Whoa, that is not at all what I was saying. I am saying we shouldn't question Black women's interpretation of what they get or see in the production as presented. I'm not saying other's can't question it that's silly and obviously gonna happen and should it's art after all. I do think non Black folks, should consider that there may be nuisance and subtleties they might miss or not pick up on which is OKAY. And if a Black person says I saw X,Y,Z...maybe not invalidate that because we are viewing it through a different perspective that might not be universal. Again, that is okay.
Also, the person above who just explained color blind casting...yeah, I can guarantee most Black folks and POC always notice when actors are color-blind cast (which honestly outside of fantasy shouldn't really be happening in realistic pieces in 2024/5 I thought we addressed this in 2020 in various forums) and it's usually odd if not the whole time there is always a moment that takes you out.