getatme said: "Genuinely surprised Eden didn't take either performance off yesterday if they start recording today. Her vocals yesterday afternoon wereshockinglyinconsistent. Noticeably flat or just under pitch for a bulk of her songs.
Enough good things cannot be said about Amber Iman or Beth Leavel, both finding ways to bring humanity and layers to an obscenely bad book. George Abud is chomping on scenery but selling his numbers despite there being minimal reason for his role to be in this show at all as he neither comes across as a true mentor or as a villain pushing machinery over art.
The design is fine, there's some good projections and some bad projections. The lighting is fun. The one platform that moves on and off on the exact same track grew tiring, as did the constant lowering of the curtain that then raise up on the exact same unit set. Hopefully Chavkin has been pouring her energy into Gatsby, because what's onstage at the Longacre was not impressive to me.
Ensemble is selling their material incredibly well, sound good, look good, choreo is good but sometimes too much.
Samonsky can sing, sure, but is utterly charmless to the point where I didn't realize until halfway through act 2 that we were even supposed to like him at all.
Eden's voice is in startling shape, truly, and I don't think she is a strong enough actor to make up for it. It was a sufficient acting performance, a wildly inconsistent vocal performance, and just unfortunately could have been something exceptional with someone who was stronger both vocally and as an actor. Not terrible, but I felt truly outshined by those around her."
Eden should take a day off this week-Tuesday or Wednesday and give her voice a rest as critics come later in the week starting on Thursday with an opening next Sunday 4/14!
"Anything you do, let it it come from you--then it will be new."
Sunday in the Park with George