I felt like one of the few people in the theatre tonight (at least in center orchestra) who was seeing this for the first time; I was surrounded by fans decked out in merch, including several who had traveled from the UK. So the audience was unsurprisingly rapturous, with sustained applause and cheers for every number. As a newbie, I thought it was terrific…clever and funny with a great score. I did miss a good portion of the lyrics in some of the rapid patter/rap songs; I don’t know whether that was a function of a not yet fully worked out sound design, the accents, my aging ears, or a combination of the above, but I do think I would have enjoyed it even more if I had familiarized myself with the West End cast recording beforehand. Other than those sound issues and a few apparently missed lighting cues, I would never have known this was a first preview; the cast obviously worked out their roles and timing long ago, and their work was precise and seemingly effortless. Jak Malone seems a lock for the Tony, though if I were voting today for Best Musical, I’d still give it to Maybe Happy Ending (which I adored and have seen twice)…but it would be close.
Director Rob Hastie gave a pre-show curtain speech and asked the audience to email him at rob@operationmincemeat.com with any reactions and suggestions. Show let out at 10:50; I didn’t note what time it started or how long the intermission was.