TNick926 said: "Hot Pants said: "I love Jonathon Groff, and he’s likely going to do a great job. However, I think he’s way too handsome to play Seymour. No matter how homely they dress him, he’s still going to look too good. I personally would’ve preferred Brandon Uranowitz. I also would’ve liked Ethan Slater as Seymour if they wanted to go for a younger actor. I think Blanchard will likely be a very good Audrey, and Borle is perfect for Orin."
In my humble opinion, you can't get any hotter than Jake Gyllenhaal, yet he was believably nebbish-y in the City Center Encores version of LSOH not too long ago (and with the incomparable original Audrey, Ellen Greene!!). I love Groff and think he can do nerdy/nebbish-y very well...
I can't wait to see this!! Love Groff, Borle, Blanchard!! Excited.... :)"
Gyllenhaal was also the wrong choice. We can't just have one Seymour that's legitimately unattractive? Or at least not like a model who we're "roughing up"? Or "nebbish-ing" up (in this context)? I love Groff and I love Gyllenhaal but there are so many "traditionally unattractive" men who deserve this part. It really does bother me. It feels like it defeats the point. I also am not holding my breath for Blanchard. Borle, on the other hand, seems perfect. To the comments above, if the Urchins were played by anything other than non-white women, I think we'd have a bigger problem. That being said, I'm sure those characters will be the only POC, aside from the Voice of Audrey II.
've only seen one Mushnik that was a person of color, and that was with a mostly black cast when I lived in North Carolina. It would be interesting to see that kind of casting in a commercial production, however, seeing as Mushnik is at this point, a stereotype of old Russian Jews which is already dicey--it seems unlikely. It would be much more exciting to see a person of color play Audrey or Seymour. Larry Owens in particular strikes me as perfect for Seymour.