Posted: 1/11/25 at 5:37pm
Georgeanddot2 said: "It sounds like you approached Audra's Rose with impenetrable preconceived notions about how that character should be played, instead of engaging with that performance on it's own terms. And yes, people who listened to a bootleg have largely dominated the conversation surrounding this performance. So much so, that the production has told the staff to be really super serious about phones being out during the show. It is IN MY OPINION (apparently we must make that very clear here) that Audra's performance is significantly more successful and interesting than anything going on in that Sunset revival and is worthy of that award.
As for a third name seriously entering this conversation, it just seems unlikely from where we stand now."
I think getting into a back and forth defending my opinion as legitimate would be a profound waste of both our times.
However regarding those bootleg recordings, I do think their influence is more than zero but not shaping the overall conversation. Any show that's a revival, the general audience is going to come in with preconceived notions. Especially a show with a movie, TV movie, and that's been on Broadway many times.
I think negatively or favorably, paying audiences are holding up McDonald's performance against Ethel Merman, Rosalind Russell, Patti LuPone, even a 60 year clip of Judy Garland singing Some People as opposed to judging her by a poor qualify recordings from people's laps.