I was there tonight and thought it was just OK, although most complaints I had were with the material itself and not this production, which despite being a little too Hipsters R Us featured some winning performances and nice directorial touches.
The Robber Bridegroom has been one of those cast recordings that no matter how many times I've tried to give it a listen the score has never hooked me. I thought maybe seeing it performed live in the context of the story would help, and it did a little, but the songs aren't exactly plot-driven, and how could they be when there's hardly any plot to speak of.
The direction was non-stop whimsy, which was often clever, but the piece never reveals itself to have a deeper level of heart, so after a while the neat ideas felt more like covering up the deficiencies of the pieces rather than enhancements. To reference [tos], it was a little doughnuts for dinner. You keep thinking, why does this remind me so much of Bloody, Bloody and Peter and the Starcatcher? Then you check the Playbill and see Alex Timbers directed and it all makes sense.
There are five or six musicians who all play their instruments on stage and sometimes take part in the action.
I think the draw here will be the performances, and everyone pulls their weight. I'm shocked Bostwick won for leading actor because is very much an ensemble affair and despite being the title character Jamie Lockhart doesn't feel like much of a showcase role. Pasquale sounds (and looks) great, but he doesn't have the meat to bite into that he had with Bridges or even Wild Party. I wasn't familiar with Ahna O'Reilly, but she made a nice impression as Rosamund. Kritzer is playing Salome to the back of Carnegie Hall, but she's getting the laughs so I guess keep it up. My personal favorites were Greg Hildreth as Goat and Andrew Durand as Little Harp.
It's pleasant enough and if you approach the production like you would Encores I think you'll have a good time.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!